5 Costly Medicare Enrollment Mistakes to Avoid

Fall Open Enrollment is now two weeks in, and the mistakes Elizabeth Bryson sees every year in Monument and the wider Tri-Lakes area tend to repeat themselves. None of them come from carelessness. They come from beneficiaries doing their own comparison under a deadline, without the full picture a broker sees across every carrier at once.

With five weeks left before the December 7 deadline, there is still time to avoid each one of these. Every mistake below has cost a real client real money or real access to care, and every one of them was avoidable with a closer look before the enrollment button got pressed.

Elizabeth Bryson has spent more than 30 years in the insurance industry, and the pattern she sees every fall across Monument, Palmer Lake, Black Forest, and Colorado Springs is remarkably consistent. One of these five gaps quietly repeats itself year after year for most people who overpay, until someone finally sits down and compares the actual numbers.

Mistake One: Comparing Only the Monthly Premium

A lower monthly premium is the easiest number to compare and the least complete one. Plan A at $0 a month can cost more over a year than Plan B at $35 a month once you add up the deductible, copays, and coinsurance you will actually pay for the care you use.

For example, a $0-premium Part D plan with a $700 deductible and 40 percent coinsurance on brand-name drugs can cost someone managing two brand-name prescriptions well over $1,500 more per year than a $45-a-month plan with a $150 deductible and flat copays. The premium alone told less than a quarter of the real story.

The only honest comparison adds up your total expected annual cost: premium, deductible, and the copays or coinsurance tied to the specific doctors, specialists, and prescriptions you actually use. A plan that looks cheapest in October can end up the most expensive by next September.

Mistake Two: Not Checking Whether Your Doctor Is Still In-Network

Provider networks reset every plan year, and a doctor’s office that accepted your plan in 2026 is not guaranteed to accept it in 2027, even if nothing about your plan choice changes. This hits Medicare Advantage enrollees hardest, since those plans build defined networks the way an HMO or PPO does.

Before switching plans, or even before staying on your current one, confirm directly with your primary care doctor’s office and any specialist you see regularly that they are contracted with the specific plan for the coming year, not just the same carrier. This matters most for people with a cardiologist, oncologist, or other specialist in Colorado Springs, since a single dropped contract can mean driving much farther for the same care, or starting over with someone new.

Mistake Three: Ignoring the Drug Formulary

Every Part D plan and every Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage publishes a formulary, which is the list of covered medications sorted into cost tiers. A medication that sat on tier two this year, often a $10 to $15 copay, can move to tier four next year, often 25 to 40 percent coinsurance instead of a flat copay, which can turn a $10 monthly cost into well over $100.

Check every prescription you take, by name and dosage, against next year’s formulary before you enroll in or renew any plan. This is the single most common gap Elizabeth finds when she runs a full comparison for a client, because most people assume their medications are covered the same way every year.

Expert Perspective: Elizabeth Bryson, Medicare Specialist

“The mistake I see most in my Monument office is usually no decision at all, someone who let their plan auto-renew without checking a single number. Auto-renewal is convenient, but convenient and correct are not the same thing, especially with a $700 Part D deductible on the table for 2027.”

Mistake Four: Missing a Late Enrollment Penalty Deadline

Late enrollment penalties are permanent, which is the part that catches people off guard. If you delay enrolling in Part B without qualifying employer coverage, the penalty adds 10 percent to your monthly premium for each full 12-month period you were eligible but did not enroll, and you keep paying that penalty for as long as you have Part B. Using the 2026 standard Part B premium of $202.90 as an example, a two-year delay adds a permanent 20 percent, or roughly $40.58 more every month, for as long as you carry Part B.

Part D carries its own late enrollment penalty, calculated at roughly 1 percent of the national base beneficiary premium for every month you went without creditable drug coverage, rounded to the nearest ten cents and added to your premium permanently. Both penalties are avoidable entirely with the right timing, and both are worth checking if you or a spouse delayed enrolling for any reason.

“Every one of these five mistakes shows up in my office every single year, and every one of them is preventable with one honest conversation before you enroll.”

Elizabeth Bryson, EB Insurance Group

Mistake Five: Waiting Until the Last Week of AEP

December’s first week is the busiest stretch of the entire Medicare calendar. Brokers, carrier call centers, and even the Medicare.gov Plan Finder tool all see their heaviest traffic in the days just before December 7, which is exactly the wrong time to be making a careful decision.

Beneficiaries who start comparing plans in late October or early November get the calmer, more thorough version of this process. Beneficiaries who wait until December 3 often get whatever appointment slot is left, not the one that fits a genuine comparison.

Expert Perspective: Elizabeth Bryson, Medicare Specialist

“I had a client last fall who enrolled in a plan a friend recommended without checking her own prescriptions against it. She found out in January that her arthritis medication had moved to a specialty tier. We fixed it during a Special Enrollment Period, but she paid full price for two months first. That is exactly the kind of thing a fifteen-minute review in October prevents.”

How to Actually Avoid All Five

Every mistake above traces back to the same fix: a full comparison across your actual prescriptions, your actual doctors, and every carrier option available in El Paso County, done with enough time to think it through. An independent broker who is not tied to one company’s plans can run that comparison in a single appointment, usually under an hour, and puts every carrier’s numbers side by side instead of asking you to track them down one company at a time.

Quick Answers About Avoiding Enrollment Mistakes

Is it too late to fix a mistake after I enroll?

Outside of December 7, options narrow, but Medicare Advantage enrollees get one more chance to switch or return to Original Medicare during the January through March Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment window. Catching a mistake before you enroll is still the more reliable fix.

Does switching plans reset my deductible?

Deductibles reset every January 1 for everyone, whether you switch plans or stay put, since Medicare deductibles run on the calendar year rather than a rolling 12-month period.

Can a broker fix a mistake found after December 7?

Sometimes, through a Special Enrollment Period tied to a documented error, but that is not guaranteed. A review before the deadline avoids needing to rely on one.

Is there a cost to use an independent broker like Elizabeth Bryson?

No. Independent brokers are compensated by the insurance carriers, not by clients, so a comparison appointment costs nothing regardless of which plan you choose or whether you choose one at all.

Watching for These Mistakes on Behalf of a Parent

If you are helping a parent in Monument, Colorado Springs, or anywhere in the Tri-Lakes area get through AEP, these five mistakes are a useful checklist to run through together. Ask directly whether their plan is set to auto-renew, whether anyone has checked this year’s formulary against their actual prescription list, and whether their doctors are confirmed in-network for 2027.

A short phone call covering those three questions catches most of what goes wrong. If anything is unclear, Elizabeth Bryson Insurance Group offers free comparison appointments that adult children are welcome to join by phone, so the whole family is looking at the same information before December 7. Many families find it easier to schedule one call together than to relay details back and forth secondhand, especially when a parent is not entirely sure what their current plan even covers.

Ready to Talk Through Your 2027 Medicare Options?

Elizabeth Bryson has spent more than 30 years in the insurance industry, with a focus on Medicare and deep roots in the Tri-Lakes community she serves. As an independent broker, she is compensated by the carriers she works with, never by the clients she advises, so every recommendation is built around what fits your coverage, not what pays her more.

Elizabeth Bryson Insurance Group | 1864 Woodmoor Dr, Suite 211, Monument, CO 80132

Phone: (719) 418-9350  |  Email: elizabeth@ebinsurancegroup.com  |  Schedule: calendly.com/ebig

Guidance is always free, with no obligation to enroll in anything.

If your 2027 Medicare coverage needs a second look, a fifteen-minute conversation with Elizabeth Bryson is the easiest way to find out.