Medicare Advantage vs Supplement for 2027

Every fall, the same question lands on Elizabeth Bryson’s desk in Monument: Medicare Advantage or Medicare Supplement? Both fill the holes Original Medicare leaves behind, but they do it in opposite ways, and the choice affects what you pay, which doctors you can see, and how easily you can change your mind later.

The Annual Election Period (AEP), also called Fall Open Enrollment, runs October 15 through December 7, 2026. Changes made during that window take effect January 1, 2027. For anyone in the Tri-Lakes area deciding between these two paths, the comparison below covers the specifics that matter most.

Elizabeth is a licensed Medicare specialist with more than 30 years of experience helping families in Monument, Palmer Lake, Black Forest, and northern Colorado Springs. She is an independent broker, which means she can compare plans from multiple carriers rather than steering you toward one.

What Original Medicare Covers, and What It Leaves Open

Original Medicare has two parts. Part A (hospital insurance) covers inpatient hospital stays, skilled nursing facility care after a qualifying hospital stay, hospice, and some home health care. Part B (medical insurance) covers doctor visits, outpatient care, preventive services, and durable medical equipment.

Neither part has a cap on what you can owe in a year. In 2026, Part A carries a $1,736 deductible for each benefit period, and Part B carries a $283 annual deductible plus a standard monthly premium of $202.90. After the Part B deductible, you generally pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount for most services, with no ceiling.

That open-ended 20% is the gap. A Medicare Supplement plan and a Medicare Advantage plan are two different ways to deal with it. Dollar figures here are 2026 amounts and are subject to annual change. The 2027 Part A and Part B premiums and deductibles had not been announced when this was written; CMS (the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) typically publishes them in November.

How a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plan Works

A Medicare Supplement plan, also called Medigap, is sold by private insurers and works alongside Original Medicare. Medicare pays its share first, then the Medigap plan pays some or all of what Medicare leaves, such as the Part B 20% coinsurance and the Part A deductible.

Standardized letter plans

Medigap benefits are standardized by letter (Plan G, Plan N, and so on). A Plan G from one company covers the same benefits as a Plan G from another, so the real differences are the monthly premium and the carrier’s rating practices. Plan G is popular because it covers nearly everything Original Medicare leaves open except the annual Part B deductible.

Provider freedom

With Original Medicare plus a Supplement, you can see any doctor or visit any hospital in the country that accepts Medicare. You generally do not need referrals or prior approval for covered services. For retirees who travel or split time between Colorado and another state, that portability matters.

What Medigap does not include

Medigap does not cover prescription drugs, dental, vision, or hearing. You add a standalone Part D (prescription drug) plan separately, and you pay a separate premium for it.

How a Medicare Advantage (Part C) Plan Works

Medicare Advantage replaces Original Medicare with a single plan from a private insurer approved by Medicare. You still have Medicare, and you still pay the Part B premium, but the plan administers your Part A and Part B benefits and often includes drug coverage.

Networks and cost sharing

Most Advantage plans use a network of doctors and hospitals, either an HMO (Health Maintenance Organization) or a PPO (Preferred Provider Organization). You pay copays or coinsurance when you get care, and every plan has a yearly out-of-pocket maximum set within limits CMS establishes each year. Once you reach it, the plan pays covered services for the rest of the year.

Extra benefits

Many plans add dental, vision, hearing, fitness memberships, or an over-the-counter allowance, often for a $0 or low monthly premium beyond Part B. These extras and their dollar limits vary by plan and change every year.

Rules to know

Some services need prior authorization before the plan will pay. Plans can also change their networks, copays, and drug lists each January, which is why reviewing the Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) letter every fall matters.

Cost Comparison: Premium Now Versus Exposure Later

The two options trade predictability in different places. Advantage plans usually cost less each month and charge more when you use care. Supplements usually cost more each month and charge little or nothing when you use care.

  • Monthly premium: Advantage plans often have $0 premiums beyond Part B. Medigap premiums vary by plan letter, age, and carrier, and many rise as you get older.
  • Doctor visits and tests: Advantage plans charge copays that vary by service. Plan G has no copays for covered Part B services after the annual deductible.
  • Hospital stays: Advantage plans typically charge a daily copay for a set number of days. Plan G covers the Part A deductible.
  • Worst-case year: Advantage plans cap your spending at the plan’s out-of-pocket maximum. Original Medicare plus a Supplement caps it through the Supplement’s coverage, with premiums being the main cost.

Someone who rarely visits a doctor may come out ahead with an Advantage plan. Someone managing a heart condition, cancer treatment, or frequent specialist visits may prefer the lower variability of a Supplement. A real comparison uses your own health history and your own prescriptions, not averages.

Expert Perspective: Elizabeth Bryson, Medicare Specialist

“In Monument and across the Tri-Lakes, I see two kinds of people regret their choice. One picked the lowest premium and later found their cardiologist in Colorado Springs was out of network. The other picked a Supplement and never realized the premium would climb every year. Neither is a bad product. They were just matched to the wrong person, and that is what a conversation up front prevents. After 30 years, I would rather spend an hour on the front end than see someone stuck in January.”

Doctor Access: Networks Versus Any Medicare Provider

This is the deciding factor for many Tri-Lakes residents. Specialists, imaging centers, and hospitals for many of us are in Colorado Springs, and some people also see providers in Denver. An Advantage plan may include those providers or may not, depending on the plan and its contracts.

Before choosing an Advantage plan, check each of your doctors, your preferred hospital, and your pharmacy against that plan’s directory, and confirm with the doctor’s office directly. Directories can lag behind actual contracts. With Original Medicare plus a Supplement, the question is simpler: does the provider accept Medicare?

The Timing Rule That Makes This Decision Hard to Undo

Switching from Advantage back to Original Medicare is generally possible during AEP (October 15 to December 7) and during the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1 to March 31, for people already in an Advantage plan). Switching works easily in that direction.

Buying a Medigap plan afterward is the harder step. Outside your first six months of Part B and certain protected situations, most insurers in most states can ask health questions and may decline or charge more. The rules vary by state and by circumstance, so ask before you give up a Supplement you already have.

The practical takeaway: people choosing between the two for the first time should think of the Supplement option as the one that is easiest to buy early and hardest to buy late.

“The cheapest plan in October is not always the cheapest plan in March. Ask what happens in your worst year, not your average one.”

Elizabeth Bryson, EB Insurance Group

Prescription Drugs Under Either Choice

Drug coverage works the same way under either path, just packaged differently. A Supplement requires a separate Part D plan, and most Advantage plans build Part D into the plan. For 2027, the Part D out-of-pocket cap is $2,400 and the maximum standard deductible is $700, though individual plans may charge less.

Formularies (the list of covered drugs) and pharmacy networks change every year, so confirm each medication, its dosage, and your pharmacy before you enroll. The next article in this series covers that check step by step.

Expert Perspective: Elizabeth Bryson, Medicare Specialist

“Both products work well for the right person. I have clients in Black Forest who are thrilled with a Supplement and clients in Palmer Lake who would not trade their Advantage plan. What I will not do is guess. If someone tells me they have a heart condition and a cardiologist in Colorado Springs they trust, that points one direction. If they are healthy and want a dental benefit, that points another. After 30 years, the plan is rarely the hard part. Asking the right questions is.”

Five Questions That Usually Settle It

Elizabeth Bryson uses a short set of questions, asked in this order, to point Tri-Lakes clients toward one option. You can work through them at your own kitchen table.

How often do you see doctors, and which ones? Frequent visits to several specialists add up under a copay structure, and a Supplement can make the year easier to predict. A healthy person who sees one primary care doctor twice a year may pay far less with a low-premium Advantage plan.

Where do you want to get care? If your answer includes a specific hospital in Colorado Springs or a specialist in Denver, confirm that the Advantage plan contracts with them. If your answer is wherever I need to go, that favors Original Medicare.

What would a bad year cost? Ask for the plan’s out-of-pocket maximum and compare it with a full year of Supplement premiums. Neither number tells the whole story, but together they define your range.

How do you feel about approvals? Advantage plans can require prior authorization for some services. Some people find that reasonable, and others find it frustrating when they are waiting on a procedure.

Do you want one card or two? An Advantage plan packages medical coverage, drug coverage, and often extras together. A Supplement means a red, white and blue Medicare card, a Supplement card, and a separate drug plan card.

“Pick the plan for the year you hope to have, then check it against the year you fear.”

Elizabeth Bryson, EB Insurance Group

Helping a Parent Choose: A Section for Adult Children

If you are helping a parent in Monument, Palmer Lake, or Colorado Springs with this decision, start with a list rather than a plan name. Write down every doctor, every prescription with dosage, the preferred pharmacy and hospital, and whether your parent travels or spends part of the year elsewhere.

Then ask three questions together. Which doctors does your parent see most often? How would a surprise hospital stay affect their budget? Would they rather pay more each month or less each month with more variable bills? Their answers usually point toward one option quickly.

Sit in on the meeting if your parent is comfortable with it, and bring the Annual Notice of Change letter if they have one. Elizabeth regularly meets with adult children by phone or Zoom when they live out of state, and her guidance is free.

Quick Answers: Advantage vs Supplement

Can I have both a Medicare Advantage plan and a Medigap plan?

No. Medigap works only with Original Medicare, and it is generally illegal for an insurer to sell you a Medigap plan if you are in a Medicare Advantage plan.

When can I switch plans for 2027?

The Annual Election Period runs October 15 through December 7, 2026, with changes effective January 1, 2027.

Does Medigap include drug coverage?

No. Medigap plans do not cover prescriptions, so you add a standalone Part D plan.

Review Your Medicare Choice With a Local Specialist

Elizabeth Bryson has spent more than 30 years helping people sort through insurance decisions, and she has lived in the Tri-Lakes area for over 20 years. She knows the doctors, hospitals, and pharmacies that people in Monument, Palmer Lake, Black Forest, and northern Colorado Springs actually use, and she will compare Advantage and Supplement options against your own list.

Elizabeth is an independent broker. She is compensated by the insurance carriers, never by you, so her guidance and the consultation are free. If you would like a second set of eyes before December 7, she is glad to meet in her office, by phone, or on Zoom.

Elizabeth Bryson Insurance Group

1864 Woodmoor Dr, Suite 211, Monument, CO 80132

Phone: (719) 418-9350

Email: elizabeth@ebinsurancegroup.com

Web: ebinsurancegroup.com

Schedule a free consultation: calendly.com/ebig

Your coverage decision should be made with people who know your neighbors, your doctors, and your questions.

Dollar figures cited are 2026 amounts or published 2027 federal parameters and are subject to annual adjustment. Plan-specific costs, benefits, and networks vary by carrier and by county.